Homemade Italian Cream Soda Tutorial and Recipe

Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version

Have you ever had an Italian cream soda?  They're delicious, right?  Now imagine how amazing Italian cream sodas can be when you make them with homemade fruit syrups.  Get ready to taste your summer obsession.

Homemade Italian cream sodas made with homemade fresh fruit syrup.

That's right, homemade, fresh fruit syrup.  Holy cow, now that's delectible.  You'll never buy the artificially flavored bottles of the stuff again once you realize how easy it is to make, and how much more delicious it is.

Watermelon simple syrup and a cut watermelon on a wooden cutting board.

You clearly don't have to make a homemade fruit syrup to make homemade Italian cream sodas (if you don't, I recommend Monin brand syrups).  But if you have bountiful summer fruit and are looking for ways to use it up, homemade syrups just can't be beat.

Strawberry Italian cream soda on a wooden cutting board on a black chalkboard background.

Either way, a homemade Italian cream soda is an amazing treat.

How to Make an Italian Cream Soda

Strawberry and Watermelon homemade Italian cream sodas on a black background.

My mom gifted me with some homemade strawberry syrup, and I'd just made homemade watermelon syrup, so I decided it was high time for me to learn how to make my own Italian cream sodas.  It's so easy, I'm ashamed I'd never done it before.

Ingredients for homemade Italian Cream Sodas

Italian Cream Soda Ingredients:

Simple syrup being poured in sparkling water to make homemade Italian Cream Sodas.

Place ice in a glass, and fill with carbonated water.  You can buy club soda or seltzer water at any grocery store, but I actually make my own.  (My husband and I LOVE sparkling mineral water, and go through several liters a day, so we bought a carbonating kit from Amazon to save money and not create so much plastic waste.)

Add fruit syrup to taste.  I don't like very sweet things, so I love making my own drinks like this so I can control the sweetness level and sugar content.  When I thought it was perfect, my girls both thought it was tasty, but needed more syrup.

Half and Half being poured in a glass to make Italian Cream Sodas

After the syrup has been added (you might need to give it a quick stir to incorporate it with the sparkling water), pour in about a teaspoon of half and half.  You don't need much at all to get that distinctive flavor and velvety feel.

Alternative to Fruit Syrup for Italian Cream Sodas:

  • If you don't have time to make homemade fruit syrups, but don't want artificial flavoring either, buy frozen, concentrated fruit juice at your local grocery store.  Let the frozen juice concentrate thaw, and use that liquid to make your Italian cream sodas.  You'll get fabulous, all-natural flavor without any fuss.

Homemade Watermelon Italian Cream Soda

Top with whipped cream and enjoy!

What are the Best Italian Cream Soda Flavors?

  • Fruit flavors are the most common Italian cream soda flavors.  But what's the best?  It depends on what fruits you love!
  • Italy is famous for its citrus crops, so lemon, grapefruit, and orange flavors are classic.
  • Don't be afraid to experiment with other fruits or fruit blends, too.  The technique can be used with fruit syrup from anywhere around the globe!

Homemade strawberry and watermelon Italian Cream Sodas

What flavor would you make?  I think I'm going to have to try peach and rhubarb, myself.  Oooh, and raspberry.

Navigational image leading reader to homemade blueberry soda recipe

Navigational image leading reader to homemade fruit simple syrups recipe

Nicole Wills, creator of Tikkido

Links on this page may be affiliate links. We may receive a small commission for something you buy through those links, at no additional cost to you.